Back to Blog

The ISL Is Dying—Not from Lack of Passion, But from Institutional Neglect

The ISL Is Dying—Not from Lack of Passion, But from Institutional Neglect

In 2026, India’s top football league is playing in half-empty stadiums while players beg to work. The real villain isn’t poor marketing—it’s a federation that treats football like a political accessory, not a national sport.

On January 3, 2026, Sunil Chhetri—India’s most-capped footballer—stood in a dimly lit room and recorded a 90-second video with fellow captains from all 14 ISL clubs. Posted on Instagram and shared by players nationwide, the message was simple:

“We just want to play football. Please help us do it.”

Not a demand for higher pay.
Not a call for better PR.

Just a plea to do their jobs.

The video, titled “Save Indian Football,” was addressed to the AIFF, FIFA, and the Union Sports Ministry.
It should’ve triggered emergency intervention.
Instead, it took three more days for the government to respond.

Because the collapse of the Indian Super League (ISL) in 2025–26 isn’t an accident.
It’s policy by negligence.

The Numbers Speak—And They’re Verified

Let’s ground this in documented reality, not speculation:

  • Average attendance has collapsed from 25,500 in 2014 to just 11,000 in 2023–24, according to Business Standard and Mint analyses of AIFF data. In Goa—a historic football hub—FC Goa drew 5,326 fans to a home game on April 5, 2024 (The Goan).

  • TV and digital viewership fell from 429 million in 2014 to 130 million by 2024–25 (Business Standard, Republic World).

  • Disney Star declined to renew broadcast rights after 2022–23, explicitly citing “persistent losses and declining engagement” (Livemint, August 2023).

  • In October 2025, the AIFF’s tender for a new commercial partner received zero bids—a first in ISL history (Times of India, October 17, 2025).

  • By December 2025, 13 of 14 ISL clubs formally wrote to the AIFF demanding it assume all operational costs or cancel the season (RevSportz, December 12, 2025).

This isn’t opinion.
It’s a forensic record of systemic failure.

The Real Crisis: Governance, Not Money

ALL Indian Football Fedaration

The trigger was the expiration of the Master Rights Agreement (MRA) between the AIFF and Football Sports Development Ltd (FSDL) in December 2025.

But the disease runs deeper.

When the AIFF floated a new tender in October 2025, it demanded:

  • A ₹37.5 crore entry fee (or 5% of gross revenue)

  • Zero operational control for the bidder

  • Acceptance of unilateral rule changes by the AIFF

“Potential investors walked away because the AIFF offered all risk, no reward,” said a former FSDL executive speaking to Sportstar on condition of anonymity (Sportstar, November 2025).

Worse, the AIFF has rotated leadership among a closed circle for over a decade:

  • Praful Patel served as AIFF president from 2009 to 2022—despite FIFA mandating his removal in 2021 for political interference.

  • His successor, Kalyan Chaubey, was a close ally and former East Bengal official.

  • Both presided over opaque finances, with the AIFF still refusing to publish full ISL revenue splits (The Hindu, 2024).

This isn’t mismanagement.
It’s institutional capture.

The “Rescue” Is a Distraction

On January 6, 2026, Sports Minister Mansukh Mandaviya announced the ISL would resume on February 14, 2026, backed by a ₹25 crore central fund from the AIFF (RevSportz, January 6).

But let’s be clear:
₹25 crore must cover 91 matches, travel for 14 teams, broadcast production, refereeing, and logistics.

By comparison:

  • The IPL’s broadcast production budget alone is ₹700+ crore/year (Economic Times, 2025).

  • A single IPL franchise (e.g., Chennai Super Kings) earns ₹425 crore annually in revenue (Business Standard, 2025).

The ISL’s entire emergency fund is less than 4% of one IPL team’s annual income.

And because the season starts in February and ends in May, it won’t meet AFC’s 8-month, 24-game requirement for Champions League eligibility—meaning India’s best clubs are barred from continental competition (Khel Now, January 2026).

This isn’t a revival.
It’s a stopgap to avoid total collapse—and even that feels temporary.

The National Sports Governance Act (2025): Real, But Unenforced

Yes, the National Sports Governance Act (NSGA), 2025, is real.
Passed by Parliament in December 2025, it mandates:

  • Term limits (max 12 years) and an age cap (70) for federation officials

  • AIFF recognition by a new National Sports Board to receive government funds

  • AIFF operations to be classified as “public authorities” under the Right to Information Act (PRS Legislative Research, December 2025)

But here’s the catch:
The AIFF has not yet complied.

As of January 2026, it still hasn’t:

  • Held elections under the new framework

  • Published financial audits

  • Allowed RTI requests on ISL revenues

Reform without enforcement is just theater.
Ask the AIFF for the ISL’s 2025 financial breakdown, and you’ll get silence.

The Human Toll—With Names and Faces

Football

While officials debate “models,” real lives are unraveling:

  • Roy Krishna, East Bengal’s marquee striker, returned to Fiji to play for Bula FC—a third-division club—because “I can’t afford to sit idle” (Times of India, January 4, 2026).

  • Adrian Luna, Kerala Blasters’ captain, accepted a loan to Persija Jakarta to secure match fitness (Times of India, December 22, 2025).

  • Borja Herrera and Javier Siverio, both key forwards for FC Goa, moved to Indonesia and Greece, respectively (RevSportz, January 2, 2026).

  • Young Indian players at academies in Bengaluru, Goa, and Delhi have no competitive pathway—their development frozen for nearly a year (Hindustan Times, December 2025).

These aren’t “market adjustments.”
They’re career derailments caused by administrative chaos.

The Ultimate Irony

India is bidding to host the 2036 Olympics, pledging ₹35,000+ crore for infrastructure (The Indian Express, 2025).
It’s building stadiums, training hubs, and “sports cities.”

Yet in 2025, it could not organize a single top-tier football match for 266 days.

You cannot build a footballing future on empty stands and silent broadcasts.
You build it on stability, respect, and institutional integrity.

The ISL had flaws—but it had momentum.
And momentum dies when those in power treat sport as a political ornament, not a national trust.

Final Thought: This Isn’t About Football—It’s About Dignity

Sunil Chhetri didn’t ask for fame.
He asked for the basic right to work.

That should shame every official who prioritized ego over athletes.

Because in 2026, India can land on the moon and build bullet trains—
but it cannot give its footballers a season.

That’s not a sports crisis. It’s a choice—to fund spectacle over sustainability, politics over people.

Until the AIFF is held accountable, until clubs have a real voice, until players are treated as professionals—not props—the ISL will keep limping from crisis to crisis.

And one day, fans won’t just stop showing up.
They’ll stop believing.

And that’s a loss no ₹25 crore fund can fix.

N

Written by Sahil

Nerdism – For the True Nerds. Exploring tech, gaming, and digital culture with unfiltered passion.

Comments (0)

Loading comments...